 35943 |
 29860 |
|
|
||
|
|
|||||||
| Register | FAQ | GFWiki | Members List | Donate | Arcade | ChocoJournal | Mark Forums Read |
| Welcome to the Gamingforce Interactive Forums. |
|
GFF is a community of gaming and music enthusiasts. We have a team of dedicated moderators, constant member-organized activities, and plenty of custom features, including our unique journal system. If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ or our GFWiki. You will have to register before you can post. Membership is completely free (and gets rid of the pesky advertisement unit underneath this message).
|
| View Poll Results: I like mine with lettuce and tomata, a big kosher pickle and french fried patatas. | |||
| 027 - OC Remix - Anachronism |
  
|
16 | 76.19% |
| 116 - Nidhoggr 2 - Edgar & Mash |
  
|
5 | 23.81% |
| Voters: 21. You may not vote on this poll | |||
 |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools |
  Member 1753 Level 36.68 Mar 2006 
|
Round 2 C06 Anachronism/Edgar & Mash
027 - OC Remix - Anachronism
116 - Nidhoggr 2 - Edgar & Mash Get the Flash Player to play this audio file: Anachronism Get the Flash Player to play this audio file: Edgar & Mash  |
Member 321 Level 26.77 Mar 2006
|
Rockified does not always a great remix make. Neither does piano either, but hell if I can place the source material (and Shnabubula's chops are clearly evident). At times in this contest, I feel I'm punishing songs whose source material I know because I can tell what's straight translation and what is real creative reimagining. Unfamiliar tunes, on the other hand, I can just evaluate on their own merit. It's a flawed system.
Anyway, Anachronism is decent enough to win here. |
Member 2441 Level 20.27 Mar 2006
|
I like Anachronism mostly for its atmosphere, which is actually very much like why I like Secret of Evermore for its atmosphere. Of course the execution is well-done too. It feels fragmentary at times, but the impressive parts make up for it. |
Member 15679 Level 10.92 Nov 2006
|
The expression in Shnabubula's playing is simply a treat, from light and delicate touches to louder "shouts" of joy. And the depth and intricacy to it... this Edgar & Mash rock rehash simply pales beside it. Sorry guys!
 A light on the water... all souls pass... |
Member 1865 Level 44.85 Mar 2006
|
027 - OC Remix - Anachronism
Brilliant, noir-tinged piano work that's a strong favorite. It took me awhile to place the source tunes, but OCRemix lept to the rescue: it's a Secret of Evermore mix, with aspects of "Halls of Collosia II," "Ivor Tower Town," and "Flying." 116 - Nidhoggr 2 - Edgar & Mash Maybe it's the memory of this song's excellent piano arrangement, but this particular version has never merited more than a "meh." Anarchonism's the clear winner for me.  From goop we came, to goop we return.
|
Member 1753 Level 36.68 Mar 2006
|
I voted for Edgar and Mash first time around, and while I love the source material to death and still come away with a good feeling from this rock arrangement, it doesn't grab me like the first time I heard it.
Anachronism, I didn't vote for. I'm correcting this oversight now. I am not familiar with the source material and that doesn't matter in the slightest bit. I must of glossed over this without paying much attention, because this is on par with professional work. This is, really, just amazing and I cannot believe a professional within the industry isn't responsible for this. It's almost certainly a front runner for me to win the whole thing now that I've payed the proper attention. |
Member 695 Level 43.27 Mar 2006
|
The abstract piano wins me over here, even though I like the clearly sectioned remix of Edgar and Mash. Probably partially because I overlistened to Edgar and Mash too. Anachronism is actually quite flowing and charming now that I listen to it again. I love the Ivor Tower part!
Spoiler:
|
