Werewolf XII: Hang 'Em High - Game Over: Good Emerges Victorious!!

Yeah, good game. The whole theme worked excellent, and while Crash had his problems with cheaters and random idiots, I'd like to applaud his commitment and talent for creating a good experience for us players.

Originally Posted by Shin

So how come the outlaws kept killing the same people as us? That really limited our effectiveness and pretty much won the game for good.

Crash says it was pretty much random coincidence. I guess nazpyro is a very good guesser The infiltrator leaked information to the natives, but played no part whatsoever in synchronizing your kills.

Originally Posted by Shin

Also, nominating Dekoa as worst player of the match. Killing two evil players and making us all waste a lynching getting rid of him, please lord let me never be on his team in a future game...

I disagree. He's one of the Most Valuable Players in this game! GJ Mates! (And a job very well done to Crash. The stats alone to this game, and its longevity, testify to the amount of work he sank into this endeavor!)

_____________________

Since I don't intend to continue providing any charts for future Werewolf games, I am attaching the template I used for Werewolf XII. Feel free to use as you see fit. Instructions are, of course, included. This requires Excel 2007 for conditional color formatting.

Yikes! Just like that it's over?

Well, it was fun watching you all in a constant state of panic and confusion, and it's gonna be a heck of a lot more fun when I come join you next time around.

Looking back, I realize that I should've played things differently, that I should've somehow made Evil believe me to be a Shaman or a Native or some other noticeably useful Good role. By not doing so, I think I stopped my role from being useful, as no one ever attempted to kill me.

That was a great game. I really enjoyed actually role-playing as a cowboy. (Maybe it was that early shotgun threat that kept everyone away...) I thank you, Crash, for handling this game so well. I thank all the players for making things interesting.

I await the next game.

Wow, I thought for certain that wvlf was a native. He kept voting with the native bloc.

Also NO WAY did the evil teams kill the same dude three times in this game as a coincidence. That never happens. Lollin though.

also assholes etc

Wvlf's lucky. If I had survived, I would've checked him, saw he was evil, and implicated him in order to get my wanted poster. I would've won the game for evil.

Your check would probably yield him as good (infiltrator). For all intents and purposes, he IS a native hidden in among the chupacabras

Originally Posted by Shin

Also, nominating Dekoa as worst player of the match. Killing two evil players and making us all waste a lynching getting rid of him, please lord let me never be on his team in a future game...

Dekoa was just an idiot, and screwed himself over. Sure, he cheated, but from my understanding, he pretty much told his entire role to Tritoch (unsolicited) without knowing whether Tritoch was good or evil. Not to mention he killed good guys, which makes me happy.

I nominate RABicle for the worst player. Outing himself as a good guy on the first day was a selfish action, because he became worthless to the side of good. On top of that, he started pretending to be a seer without an actual clue, which ended up getting me killed (sure I shouldn't be so gullible, but I didn't really think he'd be that stupid). Then he disappeared halfway through the game, so good didn't even get the benefit of a daytime vote. He's been trouble in previous games, and I think we ought to ban him permanently from Werewolf if he ever comes back.

It was fun having you guys think I was a Lunatic just to spare my life. Played you like fiddles.

Lukage was one of the few players whose role was a deliberate attempt on my part to fuck with people.

I doubted people would trust Lukage, seeing as how he's always evil. So when he started pointing fingers, I wondered how many would take him seriously.

I also figured someone would try to whack him early on, which is why he was also a Gunslinger. Sort of a double-whammy for anyone trying to rely upon past trends to figure this game out.

And he survived, too. That bugs me because he was sorta designed to die as usual.

Aaargh.

You say Lukage's is one of the few roles you deliberately designed to fuck with people? Just for laughs and giggles, would you care to elaborate on that? For the record, what's your rationale for assigning each of our roles, and what kind of goodie exactly was given for the redeemed wanted poster?

Originally Posted by Zergrinch

Your check would probably yield him as good (infiltrator). For all intents and purposes, he IS a native hidden in among the chupacabras

No, I would've gotten his role, not his alignment.

Additional Spam:

Originally Posted by Lukage

It was fun having you guys think I was a Lunatic just to spare my life. Played you like fiddles.

Okay, you see this guy? This guy who kept telling people that Locke and Mikey were evil and didn't say anything else, or act at all out of character? The one who got spared because of Zerg's hidden text?

yeah, you picked me over him, you douchewipes. I'm not even going to comment on the business he's doing because it's unsightly to insult mentally retarded children.

Additional Spam:

Originally Posted by nuttyturnip

I think we ought to ban him permanently from Werewolf if he ever comes back.

Seconded.

Are you referring to Lukage or RABicle with my quote, Lurker? Lukage is goofy, but he did introduce the game to us, and it's become a staple of the game to figure out if he's evil or just acting weird.

I want to know how Shin was dead on accurate with both the Dual Role and Infiltrator assumptions. I seriously thought us killing the same guy the second time was a coincidence, and Dual Roles came out of nowhere.

Also

Originally Posted by a lurker

Okay, you see this guy? This guy who kept telling people that Locke and Mikey were evil and didn't say anything else, or act at all out of character? The one who got spared because of Zerg's hidden text?

yeah, you picked me over him, you douchewipes. I'm not even going to comment on the business he's doing because it's unsightly to insult mentally retarded children.

I didn't check you, so it was hard to know...

Okay seriously weren't you two the first to die.

Originally Posted by Darkcomet72

I want to know how Shin was dead on accurate with both the Dual Role and Infiltrator assumptions. I seriously thought us killing the same guy the second time was a coincidence, and Dual Roles came out of nowhere.

Also

I was actually the one to bring the theory that we had an Infiltrator to Shin, though he may have been thinking the same thing already. He and I discussed it for awhile before telling the rest of you, because he'd already proven to have a dual role as a Preacher and Crash wouldn't go giving a TRIPLE role to someone. I still can't believe that all those blocked kills were entirely by chance. That's... insane.

I never really suspected wvlf of being the Infiltrator either until during the last day. He sent me a PM attempting to implicate Shin, so I planned to check wvlf as soon as the day ended. He should've implicated you or Locke instead; then I might have believed him.

It's a bit disappointing to see the game end now since I still think Evil had a decent chance at winning, but oh well.

Originally Posted by nuttyturnip

Are you referring to Lukage or RABicle with my quote, Lurker? Lukage is goofy, but he did introduce the game to us, and it's become a staple of the game to figure out if he's evil or just acting weird.

Rab, sorry.

Great game, Crash.

I hate to say it, but I think Qube fucked the Outlaws over pretty bad with the whole talking to Rat thing. We could have lasted a couple more d